TCPA Fax Lawsuit against Enclarity Proceeds

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

March 9, 2018

TCPA Fax Lawsuit

On March 5, 2018, a motion to dismiss a fax class action lawsuit brought under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (“TCPA”), as amended by the Junk Fax Prevention Act, in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois was denied. In Florence Mussat, M.D. S.C. v. Enclarity, No. 1:16-cv-07643 (Tharp, J.), the plaintiff medical practice (“Mussat”) received three form faxes over the course of three years which, they alleged, were unsolicited advertisements prohibited by the TCPA. Defendant Enclarity, Inc. (“Enclarity”) is a health care data and information solutions company owned by LexisNexis Risk Solutions (“LexisNexis”). LexisNexis is said to have the largest and most accurate database of medical providers in the United States. On behalf of LexisNexis, Enclarity sends faxes to healthcare providers seeking verification of contact information and their secure fax numbers for patients-protected health information (which must, by law, be kept secure). It then provides that information to customers. Enclarity asserted that the subject fax transmissions did not advertise the commercial availability of goods or services, as required to trigger the consent requirements mandated by the TCPA. At this stage of the TCPA fax lawsuit proceedings, the District Court disagreed with Enclarity.

Why did the Court find that the Complaint Plausibly Alleges that the Faxes were Advertisements?

The District Court relied on prior caselaw from the Seventh Circuit holding that a fax which merely describes defendant’s services, even though it may not make an overt sales pitch, may be sufficient to constitute an advertisement within the meaning of the TCPA. In evaluating the fax transmissions sent to Mussat, the Court concluded that they promoted the commercial availability of LexisNexis’ services. Critical to arriving at this decision was the fact that the subject faxes promoted that LexisNexis clients can use the solicited information for clinical summaries, prescription renewals, and other sensitive communications. In addition, the Court found that the word “client” signaled that LexisNexis provides health care provider information for a fee, meaning that its availability is commercial in nature. Further, the Court explained that the faxes at issue could be construed as a pretext to an advertisement, as part of overall commercial efforts, sufficient to constitute prohibited unsolicited commercial advertising. In reaching that conclusion, the Court explained that it was alleged that the only way to stop receiving the subject faxes was to visit the LexisNexis website, where its products and services were offered.

The Importance of TCPA Lawyers – Protect your Business from a TCPA Fax Lawsuit

We have previously blogged about TCPA-related liability resulting from fax transmissions. If your business sends communications via telecopier, it is important to take steps to ensure that your faxes comply with TCPA regulations. Not only is this a very nuanced and technical area of the law, but TCPA rulings are often inconsistent from one jurisdiction to another. As such, the importance of working closely with knowledgeable counsel prior to engaging in any fax marketing campaign is crucial.

If you are interested in learning more about this topic, please visit the Telemarketing Law practice area of our website.  If you have been served with a TCPA lawsuit, please e-mail us at or call us at (212) 246-0900.

The material contained herein is provided for information purposes only and is not legal advice, nor is it a substitute for obtaining legal advice from an attorney.  Each situation is unique, and you should not act or rely on any information contained herein without seeking the advice of an experienced attorney.

Attorney Advertising

Related Blog Posts:

Court Approval sought for TCPA Fax Class-Action Settlement

TCPA Fax Class Action Lawsuit

Fax Marketing and the TCPA

David O. Klein

David O. Klein

David Klein is one of the most recognized attorneys in the telemarketing, technology, Internet marketing, sweepstakes and telecommunications fields. Skilled at counseling clients on a broad range of technology-related matters, David Klein has substantial experience in negotiating and drafting complex licensing, marketing and Internet agreements.

Schedule a Call
In The Know

Trending Topics

New York Sweepstakes Law blog- Klein Moynihan Turco

New York Sweepstakes Law: Are You Compliant?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In general, a lottery exists when entrants pay for the chance to win a prize. States alone reserve the right to administer lotteries. Businesses can eliminate one element of what would otherwise be an illegal lottery, in order to transform it into a legal promotional game. If the requirement to

TCPA surveys

An Ad or not an Ad: NY Weighs in on TCPA Surveys

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Another day, another court decision that refines constitutes a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (“TCPA”) unsolicited fax advertisement. A Manhattan-based federal court recently issued a decision that removes faxed invitations to participate in a survey from the TCPA definition of advertisement. In drawing this distinction for TCPA surveys, the Court held

NY sports gambling law- Klein Moynihan Turco

Agreement Reached to Enact NY Sports Gambling Law

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

This week, Governor Andrew Cuomo and the New York State Legislature agreed to a budget deal that will bring mobile sports betting to the State through a unique NY sports gambling law.  Upon the Governor’s signature, NY sports gambling is primed to become the nation’s largest market. However, New York

UK and US Social Media Influencer Laws

UK and US Social Media Influencer Laws

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In September of 2020, the United Kingdom’s (“UK”) Committee of Advertising Practice (“CAP”) reviewed the Instagram accounts of 122 UK-based social media influencers to determine whether content was being properly flagged as advertising in accordance with applicable social media influencer laws. This past March, the UK Advertising Standards Authority (“ASA”)

Running a Telemarketing Business?

Get a Free Compliance Review From an Experienced TCPA Lawyer.

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin